Spain: From the (foreseeable) deadlock to the coalition government
17 janvier 2020 /
In November 2019, Spain had its fourth general election in four years to elect its next Head of Government. After two months of negotiations between the parliamentary groups of the Congress, the Socialist candidate, Pedro Sánchez, has been appointed as President.
The complex negotiations with Unidas Podemos and nationalist parties
The negotiation that came with the appointment of Pedro Sánchez as president has had several peculiarities. First, the Europeanization of the independence process, which has been a central talking point of the investiture session to the extent that the socialist candidate needed the pro-independence deputies of the Republican Left of Catalonia (ERC) to abstain on the second investiture vote. After a few weeks of uncertainty as a result of the announcement of the Spanish Supreme Court’s jurisprudence, Oriol Junqueras, former deputy president of the Catalan Government, will not be able to take his seat at the European Parliament. Meanwhile, Catalonia’s former president Carles Puigdemont and Toni Comín, former Counselor of Health of Catalonia, took their seats as members of the European Parliament and attended on January 13 the plenary session in Strasbourg. Second, the negotiations for the investiture of Pedro Sánchez, which have been marked by the allocation of ministries between the Spanish Socialist Workers’ Party (PSOE) and the far-left Unidas Podemos. Although in the previous months, Pedro Sánchez had declared that a government agreement with Unidas Podemos could not be possible, the situation today is totally different.
A socialist candidate invested as President
During the plenary session, Sánchez defended his commitment is to seek « formulas for government majorities against blockage » with the different parliamentary groups. In this respect, the socialist candidate has deemed « inadmissible » that the stalemate of the last months has stunt a stable government for a year and a half. The parties of the center-right bloc were deeply against the speech of Pedro Sánchez and accused him of “agreeing with pro-terrorist and with independentists”, which will break the unity of Spain. ERC conditioned their abstention to a bilateral negotiation table with the Catalan Government whose details have not been explained, although the PSOE insists that the negotiations will be within the constitutional framework.
After the debate between the parliamentary groups, the vote took place. Pedro Sánchez won a second investiture vote by a simple majority in which the PSOE deputies (120 seats), Unidas Podemos (35), the Basque Nationalist Party (6), Más País (2), Compromís (1), Nueva Canarias (1), Teruel Existe (1) and the Galician Nationalist Bloc (1) voted in favor. The Popular Party (88), Vox (52), Citizens (10), Junts per Catalunya (8), the Navarrese People’s Union (2), Popular Unity Candidacy (2), the Regionalist Party of Cantabria (1), Foro (1) and Canary Coalition (1) voted against and ERC (13) and EH Bildu (5) abstained.
The first Coalition government since the return to democracy
The remarkable novelty is that, for the first time in the history of Spanish democracy, a coalition government has been formed. Although coalition governments are an extended practice in most European countries, Spain had remained an exception to date. For more than thirty years, the Popular and Socialist Party administrations have alternated in government. The coalition agreement reflects the fragmented landscape that emerged in 2015, which has provoked the inability to form a single-party government.
As a result of the negotiations, Unidas Podemos occupies the deputy Presidency of Social Affairs and four ministries (Labor, Equality, Consumer Rights and Universities). According to Pedro Sánchez, the Government will address major transformations in relation to territorial understanding, social justice, the digital transformation of the economy, the ecological transition and full equality for women.
Although it is a coalition government, the approval of parliamentary initiatives will not be easy since they will need the constant support of the Basque and Catalan nationalist groups.
A Europeanist government
In December 2019, Josep Borrell assumed the post of Vice-President of the European Commission and EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy. Borrell is a key figure in the European arena. His professional career has been linked to European affairs. He has been Minister of Foreign Affairs (2018 – until his appointment as High Representative), President of the European Parliament (2004-2007) and President of the European University Institute (2010-2012). To replace Borrell, the President has proposed Arancha Gonzalez Laya. Previously to her appointment, Gonzalez Laya was the European Commission’s spokeswoman for trade and adviser to the European Commissioner for Trade Pascal Lamy (2002 – 2005) and Chief of Staff to WTO General Director (2005 – 2012). But Borrell and González Laya are not the only Europeanists: the Spaniard Clara Martínez has been appointed as Michel Barnier’s new right hand to deal with Brexit, which could give a special importance to the Gibraltar Issue in future relationship negotiations.
Manuela Sánchez Gómez is a Doctoral Candidate International Law and alumni of Institute for European Studies (ULB), as well as a Public Policy Consultant.